Twitter: Protected Updates are a False Sense of Security

Every morning I check out what happened in DC via Twitter.com for my Living in the District Blog. Basically what I do is I have an RSS feed set up that looks for “DC”, “Washington, DC”, and “Washington DC” that gets piped into my Google Reader and sometimes I randomly reply to them with @livingindc. Today I found a major Twitter bug that I think I should share.

Lately, I have seen more and more twitter users protecting their tweets so that only approved followers can read them. This morning I came across a tweet that I wanted to respond to via my RSS feed and when I went to twitter.com it said that the person had protected their tweets. But how so if I saw it in my feed. This is the problem.

I wanted to respond to this tweet.

kml73_tweet

When I went over to twitter to get the tweet to reply to this is what I got. [Link]

twitter_protected

However, if you go to search.twitter.com and search on this persons tweets this is what you get. [Link]

search_protected

I would say that this is a major security and privacy hole for Twitter users. This is a false sense of security that I think people who protect their tweets need to know about.

Twitter also has described the protect my updates setting incorrectly.

protected_rule

Protected updates are CLEARLY SHOW in the public timeline via search.twitter.com